The called lutein oil is a promising natural carotenoid food supplement that is primarily derived from Tagetes erecta L. (marigold flowers), which are in great use in the realm of nutraceutical, food, as well as feed sectors due to its visual and general well-being benefiting features. However, when it comes to this lutein oil mixture, there are two extremes: free lutein oil and lutein ester oil, which have different properties and uses. It is important that the customers learn of their differences so that they can choose the most appropriate ingredient to use in product development and in industries.
What is Free Lutein Oil?
Free lutein oil has lutein in miraculous form; in other words, the lutein molecules have not been combined with fatty acids. The form is more bioavailable, in general, because it is directly absorbable without being hydrolyzed by enzymes. Free lutein oil is generally employed where immediate bioactivity is a particular requirement, as is generally the case with softgel capsules, liquid supplements, etc.
Key Characteristics of Free Lutein Oil
Increased Bioavailability: The release of lutein molecules as unbound allows faster absorption in the body.
Formulation suppleness: It includes fewer additional treatments to recognize in an aqueous formulation or a lipid-based one.
Reduced Stability In over-processing and storage, free lutein is more susceptible to oxidation and stability loss, thus it requires special handling and needs to be antioxidant-protected.
Common Concentration: It can be found in concentrations of 5%, 10%, 15% and 20%-free lutein, assayed by HPLC.
What is Lutein Ester Oil?
Lutein ester oil is a mixture of lutein in its esterified form (i.e., as a fatty acid ester). This ester form is the one in which lutein is present in the petals of marigold. Esterification brings lutein more oxidative stability, meaning that it will give it more resilience to heat and light in manufacturing and shelf life.
Key Characteristics of Lutein Ester Oil
Increased Shelf Life and Stability: Lutein is modified into ester bonds, which increase shelf life and stability in terms of the different product forms.
Slower Release: As the lutein-ester is changed into esterified lutein, it needs enzymatic digestion in the gastrointestinal system before getting absorbed into the body, thus a slow delivery.
Industrial Suitability: Very common in soft gel and premix, in which processing stability is important.
Common Specifications: It is usually provided in 10%, 20%, and a maximum of 40% lutein ester concentration, with the higher the concentration, the lower the sufficient dosing amount.
Comparison of Free Lutein and Lutein Ester Oils
Feature |
Free Lutein Oil |
Lutein Ester Oil |
Chemical Form |
Unesterified lutein (free form) |
Lutein chemically bound to fatty acids (esters) |
Bioavailability |
Faster absorption |
Requires enzymatic hydrolysis for absorption |
Stability |
Less stable, more oxidation prone |
More stable, resistant to oxidation |
Processing |
Sensitive to heat and light |
Better suited for high-temperature processing |
Typical Uses |
Softgels, liquid supplements, formulations requiring quick bioavailability |
Softgels, premixes, animal feed, products requiring long shelf life |
Common Concentrations |
5%-20% free lutein |
10%-40% lutein esters |
How to Choose Between Free Lutein and Lutein Ester Oil?
The selection of the appropriate lutein oil relates considerably to the intended application, processing, and the required release profile:
In order to be bioactive and be available quickly, Free lutein oil is advocated since they are readily available.
To increase the stability and shelf life of the product, Lutein ester oil is more preferable because it resists oxidative pressure.
Lutein ester oil delivers enhanced resilience in heat-or light-delicate manufacturing procedures.
Free lutein oil provides easier incorporation in various systems because of its flexibility in formulation and blending.
The two forms are usually considered when manufacturers focus on cost-effectiveness, product positioning, and product compliance with the regulations.
Free Lutein Oil VS Lutein Ester Oil
To sum up, free lutein oil and lutein ester oil are significant ingredients used in the nutraceutical and feed preventive, each with its own benefits. Free lutein oil has the advantage of better bioavailability and quick absorption; however, it has to be dealt with carefully since it is sensitive. On the other hand, lutein ester oil offers improvement in stability and applicability in large-scale production that has controlled release qualities.
Are you interested in lutein oil? Just leave a message on this page or contact us directly to get free samples and more professional support!
FAQ
Q1: What is the main difference between free lutein and lutein ester oil?
Free lutein oil is composed of unesterified lutein, which is absorbed more rapidly, but lutein ester oil has lutein fatty acid-bound, and provides improved stability at a slower rate of absorption.
Q2: Which form of lutein oil is better for softgel capsules?
They may either use both of these forms or prefer using lutein ester oil in the softgels owing to its stability when heated.
Q3: Can free lutein oil be used in animal feed?
Yes, however, lutein ester oil is the most popular one as it is more stable in both feed formulas and manufacturing.
Q4: Are there differences in cost between free lutein and lutein ester oils?
Typically, the free lutein oil may be costly, owing to some processing to ensure stability and availability of the oil.
Q5: How are lutein concentrations typically measured?
Lutein concentration is normally quantified using HPLC, and the specifications are stated as a percentage of free lutein or esters of lutein in the oil.
References
1. Johnson, E. J. (2020). Lutein and Zeaxanthin in Eye and Skin Health. Nutrients, 12(2), 386.
2. Ma, L., Lin, X. M. (2019). Effects of lutein and zeaxanthin on aspects of eye health. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 99(12), 5022-5031.
3. Bernstein, P. S., et al. (2021). Lutein, Zeaxanthin, and Other Carotenoids in the Management of Eye Disease. Annual Review of Nutrition, 41, 211-236.
4. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). (2022). GRAS Notice Inventory. U.S. FDA.
5. European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). (2020). Scientific Opinion on the safety of lutein for use as a food supplement. EFSA Journal, 18(8), e06155.